ELDORADO
  • Home
  • Football
    • Super Bowl Squares >
      • How Weird Scores and Patriots-Eagles Win Probabilities Impact Your Super Bowl Squares Odds
      • How Weird Scores and Patriots-Falcons Win Probabilities Impact Your Super Bowl Box Odds
      • Your Super Bowl Box Cheat Sheet: Reflecting 2015's Weird Scores & Carolina-Denver Win Probabilities
      • Not Your Granddaddy's Super Bowl Boxes: How 2015's Weird Scores Change the Odds
    • Coin vs. Machine >
      • NFL Week 1
      • NFL Week 2
      • NFL Week 3
      • NFL Week 4
      • NFL Week 5
      • NFL Week 6
      • NFL Week 7
      • NFL Week 8
      • NFL Week 9
      • NFL Week 10
      • NFL Week 11
      • NFL Week 12
      • NFL Week 13
      • NFL Week 14
      • NFL Week 15
      • NFL Week 16
      • NFL Week 17
      • NFL Wild Card
      • NFL Divisional
      • NFL Conference Championships
      • Super Bowl LII
    • NFL Trends >
      • NFL Points and Scoring in Four Charts
      • NFL Margins of Victory in Four Charts
      • NFL Rushing and Passing in Four Charts
      • Week 8's NFL Lines Are the Lowest in a Decade
      • Margins of Victory through NFL History
      • A Complete History of NFL Points, Scores, and Scoring
    • The NFL Running Game >
      • The 2016 49ers Had the Third-Worst Run Defense in NFL History
      • How Good Was O.J. Simpson at Football? | Introduction
      • How Good Was O.J. Simpson at Football? | Analysis
      • Historical NFL Rushing Trends and Stat Adjustment Considerations
      • The Best Running Backs and Rushing Seasons in NFL History
    • Weird NFL Scores >
      • Weird Score Redux: What's to Blame, Game by Game?
      • Why 2015's NFL Scores Are the Weirdest in History
    • NFL Kickers >
      • NFL Kickers: Playoff Heroes or Goats, More So Now Than Ever Before
  • Basketball
    • Reminder: College Basketball's Dome Effect Is A Myth
    • NBA Win Projections and Offseason Improvement >
      • Introduction
      • I. The Projected Impact of the 2017 NBA Offseason
      • II. Vegas's Favorite and Least Favorite NBA Franchises
      • III. The Most Overrated and Underrated NBA Franchises
    • The Founding Fathers Warned Us About NBA All-Star Voting
    • Russell Westbrook Is the Best Non-Starter in NBA All-Star Game History
    • The 2016 U.S. Men's National Basketball Team Is an Average Version of Itself
    • When You Wish Upon A Star: The Star Makeup of NBA Championship Teams >
      • Part I: Star Makeup & Analysis
      • Part II: Noteworthy Champions
      • Part III: 2016 Conference Finalists
    • Is College Basketball's Dome Effect Real? A Study in Five Parts >
      • Introduction: Do Domes Affect NCAA Tournament Shooting?
      • The Dome Effect: NCAA Tournament Shooting by Venue Type
      • The Dome Effect: How Different Venue Types Impact Shooting
      • The Dome Effect: Offense & Defense Matter, Venue Type Does Not
      • The Dome Effect: How NRG Stadium Impacts Shooting
    • Kobe Bryant Is the Second Worst All-Star Starter in NBA History - Behind Himself >
      • Part I: NBA All-Star Voting & Player Efficiency Ratings
      • Part II: The Worst All-Star Starters in NBA History
      • Part III: NBA All-Star Voting & Value Over Replacement Player
      • Part IV: The Biggest Snubs in NBA All-Star Game History
      • Final Thoughts: Kobe Bryant Is a Star
  • Politics & Culture
    • How Long Does It Take to Exit an Airplane?
    • ELDORADO SHOWDOWN: Al Pacino vs. Robert De Niro >
      • Part I: Introduction (Tale of the Tape)
      • Part II: Box Office Receipts
      • Part III: Online Audience Ratings
      • Part IV: "The Godfather Ratings"
      • Part V: Genre Comparison
    • The Rise and ____ of Rudy Giuliani
    • Irony Trumps Hate: U.S. Presidents' American-Born Ancestors
    • Tie Colors and Memorable Moments in Presidential Debate Fashion History >
      • Tie Colors
      • Memorable Moments
    • How TV Networks Color-Coded the Parties on Election Night
    • Relative to Life Expectancy Clinton and Trump Aren't Quite So Old >
      • Introduction: The Age & Life Expectancy of U.S. Presidential Candidates
      • Analysis: The Age & Life Expectancy of U.S. Presidential Candidates
      • Appendix I: A Closer Look at Democrats and Republicans, Clinton and Trump
      • Appendix II: The Oldest & Youngest Candidates Relative to Life Expectancy
    • 'Hamilton' Is Diverse, but Is Its Audience?
  • Other
    • God, Love, Jeter & Santa Claus
  • Contact | Subscribe
NFL Week 9  |  Coin vs. Machine
3-Model and 5-Model Unanimous Picks Went Undefeated Last Week
NOV 3 2017
Week 1 - Week 2 - Week 3 - Week 4 - Week 5 - Week 6
Week 7 - Week 8 - Week 9 - Week 10 - Week 11 - Week 12
Week 13 - Week 14 - Week 15 - Week 16 - Week 17

Wild Card - Divisional - Conference - Super Bowl
Tweet Follow @eldo_co

Welcome to Week 9 of Coin versus Machine. Let's hit two quick trends and then get right into the picks.
 
(Note: A couple of neighborhoods in San Francisco lost power yesterday, which delayed this post. I bring this up because at the end of the third paragraph following this one, I implied that it might only be worth tuning into NFL games this season for Deshaun Watson. Not long after I wrote that, the news hit that Watson suffered a season-ending injury. He was all the 2017 NFL season had, and now he’s gone.)

First theme up is favorites. Back in Week 6, favorites went 5-9 outright and 3-11 against the spread (ATS), falling to a horrific 36-54-1 ATS on the season. The tide has since turned considerably. In Week 7 – when no team was favored by 7.0 points or more – favorites went 12-3 outright and 9-4-2 ATS. And in Week 8 – which had the fourth-highest average line for any week since 2014 – they went 12-1 outright and 8-4-1 ATS. Carolina was the lone Week 8 underdog to win its game, and they were barely an underdog.
 
Second is points. Through the first eight weeks of the 2017 season, the average NFL game has served up 43.8 total points. That would be the lowest points-per-game total since 2009, and it runs counter to the “evermore passing-scoring-fun NFL” that we’d grown accustomed to over the past few years. Six of this season’s eight weeks have produced fewer points per game than the average game last season. [Despite these trends, the over has cashed just as much as the under in NFL games this season (59-59-1).]
 
NFL passing yards – which correlate heavily with scoring – are at their lowest levels since 2010. And rushing yards – which have been flirting with historic lows for the past few years – are at their lowest levels since 1999. Theories about poor quarterback play and porous offensive lines have been offered. Whatever the reason, let’s hope something gives. (Or only tune in when Deshaun Watson plays.) [Postscript: F*CK]    

Looking Back at Week 8’s Picks

Three-model unanimous and five-model unanimous (Tier I “best bets”) picks ran the table last week. Both went 4-0 ATS. (It might sound odd, but the two sets of four were not identical. Minnesota, Philadelphia, New England, and Indianapolis were the three-model unanimous selections. Minnesota, Philadelphia, New England, and Kansas City were the Tier I “best bets.” Why? The three main models picked the Colts, but the other two did not. Four models picked the Chiefs and one had the line right at 7.0. That arrangement 
– four picks and one match – was originally categorized as Tier I. So in reality, "five-model unanimous" technically means “no model picked against the team.”)
Picture
Minutiae aside, it was a big week for those two pick streams. Three-model unanimous picks improved to 26-18-1 against the spread on the season (59% win percentage), and five-model unanimous (Tier I “best bets”) improved to 17-8 against the spread (68% win percentage). They’re the clear leaders across models and tiers in the year-to-date pick standings. Is it fluke? Who knows, but it continues to be worth monitoring.
 
Tier II picks – which essentially carry four-model agreement – went 1-1-1 in Week 8. At 19-23-2 ATS this season, they remain the weak link in this overall pick scheme. Not only do they carry the weakest ATS record, they violate the notion that more consensus among the models should (or could or might) mean more success in picking against the spread. Tier I has shined in that regard, but Tier II has sucked wind.
 
Tier III picks went 2-1 ATS in Week 8 (8-7 YTD), Tier IV picks went 0-1 (8-7 YTD), and Tier V “toss-ups” went 0-2 (10-10 YTD). The coin – our totally random picks – went 6-6-1 and is 54-63-2 ATS on the season.
Picture

Looking Ahead to Week 9’s Picks

With six teams enjoying their byes, Week 9 features 13 games. The three main models agree on three picks – Arizona (-2.5) at San Francisco, Seattle (-7.0) versus Washington, and Kansas City (+2.5) at Dallas.
 
Week 9’s Tier I “best bet” is Philadelphia (-7.5) hosting Denver. Like Kansas City last week, the Eagles are not a three-model unanimous pick, in this case because the actual 7.5-point line matches FiveThirtyEight’s implied 7.5-point line. But in accordance with the tier definitions we set at the start of the season, four picks and a match qualifies as Tier I (i.e., the Eagles are Tier I this week because no model picked against them.)
 
Seven Week 9 NFL picks qualify is Tier II, which is quite a few. That might sound nice, but watch out for those, as they’re only 19-23-2 against the spread on the season. Houston went from 13-point favorites to 6.5- or 7.0-point favorites on the news of Deshaun Watson’s injury. With quarterback injuries in mind, I’ve tagged the Texans and Packers for exclusion. (They’d be Tier II picks at current levels otherwise.)
 
This week’s three-model majority (“machine”) picks are actually pretty stable plus or minus one-point line movement in either direction relative to what’s presented below. The Tiers might change if your lines differ, but marginal line movement or discrepancies wouldn’t alter this week’s machine (majority) picks.
   
Picture
Tiered picks are based on the five models listed below (methodology)
​
Now let’s go find out whether the 2017 NFL season can survive without Deshaun Watson : (
Picture

The five models referenced are created by and sourced from FiveThirtyEight ("Elo"), Jeff Sagarin via USA Today ("Rating" and "Offense-Defense Method Projections"), RP-Excel.com ("R-P Excel I"), and NutshellSports.com ("Nutshell Sports NFL Ratings"). Lines are sourced from FootballLocks.com as of Nov 3 at 5pm PT. Data was compiled and analyzed by ELDORADO. All charts and graphics herein were created by ELDORADO.

​
ELDORADO  |  Berkeley, CA  |  New York, NY
​
eldo.co  |  
@eldo_co
Picture
Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • Football
    • Super Bowl Squares >
      • How Weird Scores and Patriots-Eagles Win Probabilities Impact Your Super Bowl Squares Odds
      • How Weird Scores and Patriots-Falcons Win Probabilities Impact Your Super Bowl Box Odds
      • Your Super Bowl Box Cheat Sheet: Reflecting 2015's Weird Scores & Carolina-Denver Win Probabilities
      • Not Your Granddaddy's Super Bowl Boxes: How 2015's Weird Scores Change the Odds
    • Coin vs. Machine >
      • NFL Week 1
      • NFL Week 2
      • NFL Week 3
      • NFL Week 4
      • NFL Week 5
      • NFL Week 6
      • NFL Week 7
      • NFL Week 8
      • NFL Week 9
      • NFL Week 10
      • NFL Week 11
      • NFL Week 12
      • NFL Week 13
      • NFL Week 14
      • NFL Week 15
      • NFL Week 16
      • NFL Week 17
      • NFL Wild Card
      • NFL Divisional
      • NFL Conference Championships
      • Super Bowl LII
    • NFL Trends >
      • NFL Points and Scoring in Four Charts
      • NFL Margins of Victory in Four Charts
      • NFL Rushing and Passing in Four Charts
      • Week 8's NFL Lines Are the Lowest in a Decade
      • Margins of Victory through NFL History
      • A Complete History of NFL Points, Scores, and Scoring
    • The NFL Running Game >
      • The 2016 49ers Had the Third-Worst Run Defense in NFL History
      • How Good Was O.J. Simpson at Football? | Introduction
      • How Good Was O.J. Simpson at Football? | Analysis
      • Historical NFL Rushing Trends and Stat Adjustment Considerations
      • The Best Running Backs and Rushing Seasons in NFL History
    • Weird NFL Scores >
      • Weird Score Redux: What's to Blame, Game by Game?
      • Why 2015's NFL Scores Are the Weirdest in History
    • NFL Kickers >
      • NFL Kickers: Playoff Heroes or Goats, More So Now Than Ever Before
  • Basketball
    • Reminder: College Basketball's Dome Effect Is A Myth
    • NBA Win Projections and Offseason Improvement >
      • Introduction
      • I. The Projected Impact of the 2017 NBA Offseason
      • II. Vegas's Favorite and Least Favorite NBA Franchises
      • III. The Most Overrated and Underrated NBA Franchises
    • The Founding Fathers Warned Us About NBA All-Star Voting
    • Russell Westbrook Is the Best Non-Starter in NBA All-Star Game History
    • The 2016 U.S. Men's National Basketball Team Is an Average Version of Itself
    • When You Wish Upon A Star: The Star Makeup of NBA Championship Teams >
      • Part I: Star Makeup & Analysis
      • Part II: Noteworthy Champions
      • Part III: 2016 Conference Finalists
    • Is College Basketball's Dome Effect Real? A Study in Five Parts >
      • Introduction: Do Domes Affect NCAA Tournament Shooting?
      • The Dome Effect: NCAA Tournament Shooting by Venue Type
      • The Dome Effect: How Different Venue Types Impact Shooting
      • The Dome Effect: Offense & Defense Matter, Venue Type Does Not
      • The Dome Effect: How NRG Stadium Impacts Shooting
    • Kobe Bryant Is the Second Worst All-Star Starter in NBA History - Behind Himself >
      • Part I: NBA All-Star Voting & Player Efficiency Ratings
      • Part II: The Worst All-Star Starters in NBA History
      • Part III: NBA All-Star Voting & Value Over Replacement Player
      • Part IV: The Biggest Snubs in NBA All-Star Game History
      • Final Thoughts: Kobe Bryant Is a Star
  • Politics & Culture
    • How Long Does It Take to Exit an Airplane?
    • ELDORADO SHOWDOWN: Al Pacino vs. Robert De Niro >
      • Part I: Introduction (Tale of the Tape)
      • Part II: Box Office Receipts
      • Part III: Online Audience Ratings
      • Part IV: "The Godfather Ratings"
      • Part V: Genre Comparison
    • The Rise and ____ of Rudy Giuliani
    • Irony Trumps Hate: U.S. Presidents' American-Born Ancestors
    • Tie Colors and Memorable Moments in Presidential Debate Fashion History >
      • Tie Colors
      • Memorable Moments
    • How TV Networks Color-Coded the Parties on Election Night
    • Relative to Life Expectancy Clinton and Trump Aren't Quite So Old >
      • Introduction: The Age & Life Expectancy of U.S. Presidential Candidates
      • Analysis: The Age & Life Expectancy of U.S. Presidential Candidates
      • Appendix I: A Closer Look at Democrats and Republicans, Clinton and Trump
      • Appendix II: The Oldest & Youngest Candidates Relative to Life Expectancy
    • 'Hamilton' Is Diverse, but Is Its Audience?
  • Other
    • God, Love, Jeter & Santa Claus
  • Contact | Subscribe
✕